1) I meant 25m. In my opinion 10m and 25m are different enough that you can't just lump them together. Method is considered "world first" even though paragon technically did it first simply because the race is about 25m content, no?
2) the 4pc is good. It's been hotfixed to affect our shield, which makes it completely worth it despite the slight mastery loss compared to non-tier pieces.
Your guild is definitely more progressed than mine is, but if im not mistaken it also raids 25 hours a week (im sure less now that the tier is over) compared to my guild which raids 16. those 9 hours/week make a difference. Regardless of our guilds ranks however, theorycrafting doesnt care how good your progression is. Back up your attacks on me with theorycrafting, not "my guilds killed 3 more bosses than your guild so i'm right". You still haven't defended your claim that "hit cap is mandatory".