Then I took my current gear and did the same.
This profile is my current gear: http://chardev.org/?profile=305072
Notes: atm I cannot afford epic gems and therefore I have to use 2 non-stamina trinkets. I could reach it with 1 stamina trinket and the elixir combo but I prefer the cauldron . At least I could squeeze in 4 Stamina Gems. Anyways the result is CTC and 209933 HP
Then I replaced every gem with a stamina gem and replaced the current trinkets with stamina trinkets which i have available. This is the profile http://chardev.org/?profile=305090
The result is 90.3% CTC and 249427 HP.
so it ends up being roughly a 40k Hp diffrence. Thats almost 20% more then in the other setup its like a perma Rallying Cry
Lets run these setups in a worst case scenario on heroic morchok:
Stomp -> Hit -> Hit in the Sta. setup and Stomp -> Block -> Block in the CTC setup.
according to WOL I take about 40k Hits on average and the stomp is about 105k
Stamina Setup: 249k-105 -40k -40k = 64k (25%)
CTC Setup: 210 -105- 28 - 28 = 49 (23%)
So the stamina setup has a slightly better outcome on top of that you would also trigger pride after the first hit but since its a worst case it didn't proc . So if your gear isn't top notch the stamina setup might be at least a viable approach and as soon as your gear progresses and ctc is easier to obtain stamina after ctc is the way to go.