Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: So here's the thing...

  1. #1
    Join Date
    May 2011

    So here's the thing...

    Hi guys, I'm a fresh 85 Tankadin with a iLvl of 334 - enough to tank Heroics apparently. I have a few questions to ask and hope you guys can help me out Much thanks in advance.

    Please note that some are character related but refer to my character in the sense of heroics. Please find my character link below:

    a) What is the best red gem to gem with for tanking heroics?

    b) I've found since the jump that I'm struggling to cope a little with the new dynamics - is this because of my gear? I find that people are easily pulling aggro of me.

    c) Ideally what should be my rotation in both single and multi targets? I find i'm using the same amalgonated rotation, which is effective in single target but not multi target.

    d) As a tank, which are the easiest dungeons to queue for? As if it's a question of my gear thats causing me trouble in other tank-unfriendly instances, this would allow me to gear up.

    Thanks so much for your patience! and sorry if this is in the wrong section!

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    WI, USA
    a) As a Protection Paladin, you will want Mastery everywhere until such time as you are capped or are in heroic raid content. Fine Ember Topaz is the ideal cut for a red socket as it is the only combo gem that has both Mastery and another tanking stat.

    b) You are expected to be able to hold threat against those of comparable gear. As a 333 tank, you'd expect to be able to hold threat against a 333 DPS. If your DPS outgears the context, i.e. a 359 DPS, then you aren't expected to be able to hold threat off of them. You will have to be more specific with your question if you feel it is actually a problem you face.

    However, given your current state I would say you wouldn't even be able to hold aggro off of an equivalently geared DPS. You have no enchants, no reforging, no gems, and no glyphs. Since you haven't made any investment in what you have, your performance will be considerably less than that of your average 333 player who has made such investments. Not saying you have to go for broke and get best of everything, but you should have something invested, especially in those pieces of gear which are higher in item level than your current context (i.e. your 346 and 353 pieces should definately be enchanted). You also aren't receiving the benefit of your professions as they aren't high enough in level to be granting their Cataclysm bonuses.

    c) No comment as I don't play a paladin myself.

    d) There is one "tank-unfriendly" encounter in heroic dungeons. Cookie. That fight requires no tanks. Everything else requires a tank therefore is a tank friendly encounter. The term unfriendly when refering to a role, like "melee-unfriendly" means there are mechanics which favor having ranged players instead of melee. There is never a case though where you would choose to not have a tank. In terms of actual difficulty though it will vary depending on your own skills. What one person considers hard, another considers easy. Some will consider execution based context to be hard. Others may consider them easy because once you execute them properly it is easy to have repeat success. Others will say things like throughput tests are hard simply because if you lack the necessary throughput you can't succeed regardless of your technique. Others will say those are easier because once you have the necessary throughput there is considerably less you are required to learn to deal with. Difficulty is often a matter of perspective.

    Also, this topic should be in the HALP forums as it pretains more to your character. It has relatively little to do with dungeons.
    Last edited by Quinafoi; 06-20-2011 at 12:02 PM.
    "In anything, if you want to go from just a beginner to a pro, you need a montage." /w TankSpot WTB Montage for Raiders.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Thanks for your input If a mod could move this, I'd be really grateful


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts