Windwalk Vs. 130 Agi

[Rinion]

For druid tanking, which is better? Windwalk (600 dodge rating proc) or 130 Agility? I currently have Malevolence and am wondering which is better overall. If you have any logs to back up the proc being better please let me know.

[Darksend]

I prefer agi, but then again I am the guy who used 35 agi over mongoose because of my legendary hate of procs vs passive stats

[Chanserv]

I'd vote for the Agi one, going to help your SD out more then the dodge would.

[Katarn]

Ehhh, there hasn't really been enough data available to determine Windwalk vs 130 Agility. Personally I'm sticking with 130 Agility for now.

[MellvarTank]

I'd recommend Agi for a bear.

[Kojiyama]

Windwalk is technically about 25% more mitigation than Agility. Then again, it's not up all the time and has no threat component.

Depends on if you think 0.8% mitigation or so is worth the inconsistent nature of the proc. Personally, I'm sticking with Agility but I suppose it's not a massive difference either way. (Agility will also be a lot closer at lower gear levels, as the SD gains are a bit more valuable then.)

[Katarn]

Windwalk is technically about 25% more mitigation than Agility. Then again, it's not up all the time and has no threat component.

Depends on if you think 0.8% mitigation or so is worth the inconsistent nature of the proc. Personally, I'm sticking with Agility but I suppose it's not a massive difference either way. (Agility will also be a lot closer at lower gear levels, as the SD gains are a bit more valuable then.)

Additionally the value from Windwalk will decrease faster than 130 Agility as we progess through this expansion.