BaleBrew Charm or Ick's Rotting Thumb?

[scotladd]

With 4.0 it would seem to me that the dodge/mastery option and health boost would outweigh the 170 stam. Especially given the Health/DPS buffs that everyone is rocking now. Thoughts?

Current Mitigation is 20/19/41 with 49k unbuffed health.

[uglybbtoo]

Given your stats ick and reforge IMO

[MellvarTank]

I HATE the brewfest trinkets... enough that I would say Ick's is better.

[Punchdrunk]

I was struggling with trinkets too, because they took the armor out of Glyph of Indomitability and just left an on use dodge effect. I decided to go with Ick's and reforge to mastery. I have a macro that ties its on-use to Last Stand, which makes the health boost of last stand even better. My other option was Black Heart, and I am still torn between the two.

[Bashal]

I was struggling with trinkets too, because they took the armor out of Glyph of Indomitability and just left an on use dodge effect.

That was a bug; the armor is back on indom now.