Out of those four? CSK and the twilight scale. You're tanking the adds in P1, does that mean you're not really tanking lich king at all? since there are many different ways people handle that. LK himself will not stack your organ up appreciably, he stops and casts too much, frostmourne rooms, etc. He's a boss where health is almost always better than the other options, similarly if you're offtanking the armor won't do you any good soaking viles since it's magic damage, but given that your only listen options include only one stam trinket, might as well go with the superior non-stam in the scale.
TBH though if you have either a satrina's/juggernauts available to you go with those instead until you can get a flawless fang.