In your view, just how important is this talent? I keep getting asked to put that on dps members, usually in random pug groups. I have never had this point and am thinking of redoing my tree for it.
Is this really worth it?
I like it and use it. The reduced threat can make a huge difference. One important feature thats also helpful sometimes is the refresh on Taunt.
That said, I don't know what the consensus is regarding who to put it on. I had always defaulted to healer or maybe a threat-limited ranged dpser like warlock, mainly because it made my job easier (mobs I haven't tagged are less likely to run away from me) and helped me deal with problem situations. But lately I've been getting these ret paladins (every single time, a paladin) that treats me like an idiot for not putting it on him to begin with.
Is this really how it's used by most people? I have a couple high dps pallies in my guild and they don't pull aggro from me, so it had never even occurred to me before the random LFD thing came out.
I rarely use it in 5mans, there are a few occasions where I will (Bladestorm arms warrior comes to mind...) but it really shines in raid content where a lot of warriors drop threat gear/enchants/gems for survivability gear/enchants/gems and the dps just keep on getting higher and higher threat per second (TPS).
Overall I'd say it's a very nice talent to have, regardless of raiding or not.
I use it a lot on Hunters. If there's no hunter, I'll stick it on a lock. If there are no hunters or locks, it goes on a warrior.
Yes, I know Hunters have Feign Death. They still put out possibly the highest threat of all the dpsers, and even if they don't need the reduction from threat, I could use the 10% of what they put out.
Highest dps does not equate highest threat. Paladins and smart dks have very low threat output, for example(presence/default reduction + 30% reduction). Warriors and Hunters are on top, locks a close second. Rogues third, and then roughly everything else.
For aoe...unholy dks pull ahead, rest's the same, tho warriors probably still have an edge in threat gen there.
So yeah, vigilance those guys in brown, green or purple colored names.
I generally put mine on the highest dps for general use. For taunt swapping fights like gormokk, Deathbringer or Festergut I put it on the OT, and for Rotface since im the slime tank I put it on the healer with the most heals, as they have the potential to aggro the big slimes.
I always put it on whatever DPS is highest on Omen. Putting it on another tank on paper sounds nice, but they hate it; it's a tank thing.
As a tank, even though I'm confident in my threat generation, I'm still very uneasy about it being put on me if I'm not putting my Vigi on the other Prot Warrior.
"Humility doesn't remove the crown from your head - it shows why you deserve to wear one."
Just helps on the inital pickup in case im not close enough to shield slam it before it goes active.