I have 4 weapons at my disposal.
Item Comparison Tool - World of Warcraft
I currently use Titanguard w/ Accuracy enchant (hit & crit).
I believe that, for non-threat related fights, I would use Rimefang's Claw.
Any suggestions on the enchant for the Claw?
Any suggestions/opinions that I should use the others for certain types of fights?
ardent guard would be best for EH fights with the added armor.
as far as threat goes i THINK (but do not know) that rimefang's claw would be best
It would be best on threat only if I was hit capped, which I am not w/o Titanguard
Hit is really not that important for threat (well not as important as expertise), I would any day use ardent guard, the only exception would be the axe if you are an orc and you need the racial expertise.
Good read: Expertise is always better than Hit - Warriors - TankingTips.com
Ardent Guard - For EH fights. (Algalon, Anub, Icehowl)
Titanguard - For fights you don't want to miss an important taunt\interrupt. (Gormok, (H)Lord Jaraxx)
Rimefangs Claw - Avoidance. (Anub Adds, Gunship, Saurfang)
Faric's Wrist-Chopper - Block set. (Can't really see any use except for Anub adds or tanking heroics)
Edit: As for Enchants, I would enchant according to what you need when you have that specific item equipped. (i.e. If your way low on hit with Ardent Guard equipped, put Accuracy on it.)
Last edited by Warrenar; 12-15-2009 at 10:49 AM.