I currently have Juggernaut's Vitality and The Black Heart. I just picked up Ick's Rotting Thumb. Should I switch? Or what? I am at 45.2k HP in bear and 42.23% dodge. Just wondering if I should pick up dodge over stam.
Switch them out depending on the fight.
For the majority of fights EH.
given your current gemming and enchanting choices, you have way more avoidance than I do already.
black heart + jugs
also consider if you dropped black heart than you would have 2 trinkets that share a 3 minute cooldown, in case you were not aware.