Quel'Delar

[Hapa]

So been recently trying to compare the new quest line. For the reward of option of Quel'Delar. Did some basis stat weights, and I'm really up in arms which is overall best choice for Arms DPS. Some help would be greatly appriecated since 50,000 heads are better then one.

Item differences are

Quel'Delar, Ferocity of the Scorned - Items - Sigrie
Gains
144 Agi
197 AP
91 Armor Pen (7.39%)
0.2 Melee DPS

Quel'Delar, Might of the Faithful - Items - Sigrie
Gains
28 Sta
164 Str
91 Haste (2.78%)
42 Melee Min Damage
64 Melee Max Damage
0.2 Melee speed

[Hapa]

Still seeking some imput, from what I'm getting the Agi version for Crit / ArP will beat out the higher top end, just hoping this can be confirmed by folks who are in same boat of choosing.

[Muffin Man]

I think it really depends on your gear. How close to the soft cap are you? The slower speed and increased damage on the sword might be better if you're close to soft capping. OTOH, the agi version is pretty well itemized since haste is so awful for Arms though.