If your raid leader blames the tank when the boss enrages and wipes the raid you have one very clueless leader. Dps dps tanks reduce incoming damage and do tps our dps is a bonus. If dps was what we were suppose to do you can fury tank. Its no secret that prot warrior dps is probably the lowest of all the tanks but if you bench them for that you should first clear your roster of your subpar dps.You can say oh whatever but increasing raid dps by 1-2k at the loss of mechanics that aren't even useful on single-target boss fights such as stuns and spell reflect is a pretty big deal. And here inlays the root of the problem, balancing pvp and pve.
Last i checked warriors ruled the earth till lich king. Ok so we make trash pulls easier does that mean we need a nerf o so bad to let other tanks in on the trash, not really its trash. As for boss tanking I dont see us needing a nerf asap. i would say DKs need a buff more than we need a nerf right now.What irks me about this though, is the fact that this situation ONLY happens to us. I guarantee you, if it was the opposite case, where warriors were dominating and paladins were where we are in terms of threat/survivability and quality of life, something would be done within the week.
Blizzard did release pandora from her box when they made pallies really powerful aoe tanks. I dont think Blizzard should make every tank capable of what the other can do, tanking is a team game thats why there are 3 of you in a 25 man raid. If your pallie can aoe well then as a warrior pick out the target that needs to be dead first and have people assist off you or stun the group or for that matter disarm the whirlwind guy. Before you go say Pallies are OP try tanking Suarfang with 2 pallies (it can be done but a lot easier to put tanks without aoe/cleave in there rotation).