Yep finally after all the discussion everyone is on the same page there is not a huge difference in any of the tanks but some adjustment will be needed going forward.
Throw one into the mix for going forward standardize the stamina base between pally's and warriors get rid of the stupid libram and let us have a gun ... come on GC that libram crap is retarded anyhow.
The real question for pally's is the AD overpowered. I hate it on my pally I would have preferred something I could use pre-emptive of damage rather than something that is outside my control. Everyone talks about how wonderful it is but they forget it's on an uncontrolled CD so you get belted into the AD zone which was a small spike which you may have even expected the dam thing procs you didnt need it but it procs anyhow. 1 min later when you really really do need it well it's in CD.
The funny thing I find now is since the nerf I actually think its more powerful because you dont get false triggers as high up your HP pool. Actually if they could drop it another 5% I would be really happy.
** Remember Warcraft players fail in directions you never thought possible.