8/10, nice and clear, but lots of information at the top, the buff edges being rounded as opposed to the clean lines of the rest of the UI, cluttered minimap buttons and keybinds shown spoil the effect of the UI for me.
Functionally it felt ok , but it was missing that 'flair' the popular UI's had so I tried out kgpanels (i'd recently downloaded satrina buff frames aswell, but it just needs a little tweaking-and before you jump down my throat about it I recently disabled that 'behind your target' spam aswell)
And, well...i'm not exactly pro with photoshop and it just feels very 'sloppy' if you know what I mean. I really think I could get away with using the btex bottom bar again, but if anyone could throw me any suggestions regarding kgpanels i'm all ears.
Well raid frames, ie grid would be in upper left, and then boss mods would be up below my debuffs a bit etc you know you can hide that DXE window right,?
If i got threat mods, it would be in the lower right along with skada
The little bar above the minimap/buttons is a swing timer.. Its useful, well maybe not so much tanking but its great for usign big slow weapons as a warrior >.<
You seem to have a ton of clutter on your frames, Make your buffs smaller!, I really hate sexycooldown, I never look at it.. I rarely look at when any cooldowns are up, Im thinking about turning them all off except maybe shieldwall /last stand.. Hide your DXE window since it seems to be out place, your upper left corner is unused, i'd personally move raid frames up there since you never really need to care about that since your not a healer..
Define 'clutter'? (be more specific), I have the DXE window enabled because i'm not targetting the boss 100% of the time. I have my buffs big because I don't like to squint to see what i've got, less time looking at buffs=more time doing something useful. The sexycooldown is likely just a playstyle thing-you said you only really monitor a select few cooldowns whereas I like to time my trinkets with berserk, it also helps to track my cooldowns on rebirth/innervate/survival instincts/etc. I'm not a healer yes, but I do often have to battleres/innervate people. Maybe i'll move the main DXE window down a bit so it doesn't look out of place.
Just found this thread
Gonna rate the UI above me 6/10 a little too messy for me at least.
I'll go ahead and show you my recently made ui, works well for me
if you wanna see a video of it in action you can check out one of my boss kill vids: Blood Queen:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78t2Ep35PlE
Look forward to your rating
1. You really don't need your bag bar visible
2. Grid seems out of place with the entire lower right section of your screen being unused
3. You can move omen to the left of your action bar, and change the background to fit your action bars background, and you can move recount to the right side and do the same
4. The background on your chat window doesn't match the rest of your theme
Everything else seems to be setup pretty nicely
Thanks for the rating. My bag bar is somewhat a divider/semi-border for grid/recount. I tend to focus more on the left hand side of my screen (hence the positioning of grid/omen). I used a darker background for the chat frame for contrast, not sure how well a lighter background on the chat box would look.
Have to say I like the use of KGpanels in Khilbron's ui, everything looks like it 'belongs' there (are you using grid? i've seen a few raidframes with that look, tried revering the colours on grid but could never quite that 'look'-and whats your screen resolution?) 9/10
Here's mine again, i'd like a more detailed response than 'cluttered' if possible
Shrank buffs slightly and moved dxe window down to chat box, don't have a decent screenshot to display it at the moment.