Holy Paladin Rings.

[Oblivion]

I've got four holy rings, all the same ilevel, all fairly similarly itemized for the level. I did some reading and couldn't find any really clear distinction on which is more desirable. Any input would be much appreciated.

Circle of Life - Item - World of Warcraft
Band of Neglected Pleas - Item - World of Warcraft
Band of Guile - Item - World of Warcraft
Signet of Hopeful Light - Item - World of Warcraft

[Zabery]

Here's a comparison of the rings in wowhead:

Item Comparison Tool - World of Warcraft

Here's how I gear to give you an idea of where I'm coming from:

WoW Heroes - World of Warcraft PvE character info & ratings

Here's my take:

Int, we love int: Hopeful Light, Neglected Pleas
Crit, we love crit: Neglected Pleas
SP: all the same
Haste: we tend to get enough without prioritizing, don't stress it
MP5: I avoid MP5, it's a trivial percentage of our mana regen at a huge itemization cost.

I'd grab Hopeful Light and Neglected Pleas. If you can afford it, though, take a look at the Titanium Spellshock Ring - Item - World of Warcraft. I'd ignore the Spell Power socket bonus and throw an int gem in it. It's easily one of the strongest pre-25 holy pally rings.

Finally, check out Siha's post on pre-raiding gear, if you haven't already:

Pre-Raid Holy Paladin Gear List, v.1 - Banana Shoulders

[Oblivion]

Beautiful. My initial thought was to go with the Neglected Pleas and Circle of Life, so getting some more information from someone more experienced with the mechanics of Holy than myself is very appreciated. Took a long look at the pre-raid gear as well and took a lot of good information from there as well.