This is my Armory, hopefully it's correct since I've been fiddling with gear swapping and gems all day.
Basically, I have listened to a lot of back and forths and different advice from different people that's very conflicting and confusing, especially on block rating vs pure avoidance.
This is the current gear I've chosen to wear, although I have a small block set and some other random pieces as well:
Tempered Titansteel Helm
Tempered Titansteel Boots
Valor Medal of the First War
Terrace Defense Boots
Heroes Redemption Breastplate
The Skull of Ruin
Waistguard of the Tutor
On future loot, I'm restricted to 10 man rots (I'm Holy as my main spec), so...
Basically I'm stuck at what to further. I've been swapping around gear all morning trying to find a happy balance but the last few pieces I picked up seem to have kinda thrown a wrench in my whole plan.
So a couple of questions I have
1.) I'm fresh to tanking and the math involved, so what would my total mitigation/avoidance count be currently unbuffed as a Prot Paladin? I know I'm trying to aim for 102.4 but I don't understand how the reduced chance to be hit, etc, scales onto bosses.
2.) Between my profile and my spare gear, is there any path I should be heading for specifically? Any advice in general here would be super helpful. I'll take any advice on item swapping or regemming or anything, really, I feel like I'm at a dead end here.
you can download the addin tankadin which will give you a good view on where you are vs the 102.4%. First, for an 'off set' you've got really good gear. Right now, you should be at around 100-101 toward block cap. Basically, your dodge+parry+block is 60%. Your miss should be 10-11% and HS will add 30%. You're critable right now (def 537), but I assume that's just part of the gear testing swap out rather than a fundamental problem.
As a quick gear up grade, you might want to try to get the boots that drop off of noth in reg naxx. They'd be better than the titansteel. Regardless though, fix the uncritable bit and you can tank 25 mans fine.