EDIT: just re-read your post sry I misunderstood the first time I read it.
Post WWS and we can reply maybe, but in my experience, a Fury warrior would be more helpful than the Ret pally for the group. Two warrs also give shouts that help your melee's survivability and dps. Pally just boosts DPS really. SO I'm leaning towards the Ret pally as a replacement.
Does the Fury warr have Solarian's btw?
PS he might not ever reach the rogue's damage output per second, but time on target, and time alive might be exponential improvements over rogues who can die nasty, squishy deaths. All things being equal though, I really haven't raided at that level yet, so these are just gut thoughts.
Last edited by GarrettJaxx; 07-17-2008 at 07:51 AM.