Search:

Type: Posts; User: Esch; Keyword(s):

Search: Search took 0.00 seconds.

  1. Replies
    57
    Views
    3,680

    Mute - Kinda irrelavent. You can run raids with a...

    Mute - Kinda irrelavent. You can run raids with a large portion (~80%) never saying a word. Heck, some folks function better when they shut up, strangely :rolleyes:

    Deaf - It would depend a lot of...
  2. Replies
    13
    Views
    2,699

    Paladin The question, from my view, is if you can...

    The question, from my view, is if you can reliably out threat DPS, how valuable is giving all healers +300 spellpower that heal/shield you? The biggest aspect is understanding the proc isn't helpful...
  3. "Kill LK with a Shadowmourne in raid for bonus...

    "Kill LK with a Shadowmourne in raid for bonus loot, all vanity items". There was a list on MMO-Champion a bit ago, but I never checked back on it. I'll worry more when LK is dead and my group is...
  4. Replies
    81
    Views
    4,101

    I'm lukewarm to achievements, though I prefer...

    I'm lukewarm to achievements, though I prefer them far more than the original event idea. I'm not saying this is a bad idea, but it would take a considerable amount of work to create, actually do and...
  5. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    You mean, the movie, the popcorn, the candy and...

    You mean, the movie, the popcorn, the candy and the soda... gotcha. So, the entire point of the game revolves around getting to level cap, at which point you can do anything as you paid the price (in...
  6. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    Umm.... kettle... black? :confused: ...

    Umm.... kettle... black? :confused:



    You're only confusing me more here. The core of the idea is to utilize things players are going to do anyways, both to attune them and to present future...
  7. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    Strangely, this idea comes from your blog, where...

    Strangely, this idea comes from your blog, where you listed the sheer number of instances you've run. If you're going to run those instances anyways, why is it unreasonable to employ those as both...
  8. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    I'm still pretty firmly set on some sort of...

    I'm still pretty firmly set on some sort of attuning for raid content. (Humor me)

    The crux of opposition to attunements is that they are unnecessary time sinks in order to be allowed to enter...
  9. Replies
    81
    Views
    4,101

    lolwut? Content hasn't gotten easier, so much...

    lolwut?

    Content hasn't gotten easier, so much as accessing appropriate gear has become almost trivial. My druid alt, the most recent 80, is already in a mix of 232/264 badge items from running...
  10. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    Regretfully, I don't feel the verbage states what...

    Regretfully, I don't feel the verbage states what you're envisioning. I suggest clarification along the lines of 'you acquire a key appropriate for your role'. Otherwise, as I am arguing, it can be...
  11. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    A lot of the reward for completing the attunement...

    A lot of the reward for completing the attunement quest was the effort demonstrated both skill and commitment. The challenge you proposed attempts to demonstrate a player can fulfill at least one...
  12. Replies
    81
    Views
    4,101

    I think you're overlooking my point. What...

    I think you're overlooking my point.

    What you're aiming for is a solo event to determine if a player is capable of specific content, and using it to enable players to participate in that content....
  13. Replies
    81
    Views
    4,101

    Meaningless test is meaningless? The social...

    Meaningless test is meaningless? The social community is where determining someone's raiding skill belongs.

    EDIT: Okay, that was rude. My point is that I see a method enabling raiders to decide...
  14. Replies
    81
    Views
    4,101

    Funny, I specifically avoided 'reputation' as I...

    Funny, I specifically avoided 'reputation' as I know how unpleasent that grinding it. However, asking players to put forth enough time, effort and focus to complete a series of instances (arbitrary...
  15. Replies
    81
    Views
    4,101

    Reduce entire attunement process to a solo event....

    Reduce entire attunement process to a solo event.

    no.

    Why? Largely as it's meaningless. Grats, you can respec to X role for Y class, go do that, and you're done. It's not going to be a...
  16. Replies
    440
    Views
    20,285

    I like attunements to be enough of an effort, to...

    I like attunements to be enough of an effort, to require an effort to achieve them. I don't like extremely long, convoluted steps that rely on completing every ... little... bit... else you're...
  17. Replies
    7
    Views
    1,145

    Frankly, unless you're pressed for his specific...

    Frankly, unless you're pressed for his specific tank, I'd directly tell him he's disruptive. If he can't understand the concept that the tank corps is more important than any individual tank, he's...
  18. Replies
    233
    Views
    31,927

    Death Knight The toolboxes, however, are consistent. All...

    The toolboxes, however, are consistent. All healers have some sort of cleansing (with GC already stating that making it possible for any healer to remove any debuff being a Cataclysm consideration),...
  19. Replies
    233
    Views
    31,927

    Death Knight Actually, it's kinda hard to get it in my 25...

    Actually, it's kinda hard to get it in my 25 group, which is why it's annoying. It's taken a fair number of discussions to get the debuff in raids, rather than reliance on a DPS's spec and/or...
  20. Replies
    233
    Views
    31,927

    Death Knight The stigma of being an 'OT' still lasts from MC...

    The stigma of being an 'OT' still lasts from MC content, where two tanks handled 'trash' until the raid could deal with the 'boss'. Until WotLK, if you weren't the MT, you were a lesser tank and thus...
  21. Replies
    233
    Views
    31,927

    Death Knight I had to double double check, and I'm going to...

    I had to double double check, and I'm going to have to metion this tonight. The 'fine print' eluded me when I was discussing this last night. We (myself & raidmate) misconstrued the tooltip. Blargh.
  22. Replies
    233
    Views
    31,927

    Death Knight I'm very excited myself, as I function as a Frost...

    I'm very excited myself, as I function as a Frost tank to provide Imp Icy Talons (Windfury) to the raidgroup. With both a possible recruit/replacement for that buff and the DK changes, I'm looking...
  23. Thread: Dk tanks

    by Esch
    Replies
    42
    Views
    5,552

    The crux of the AP debuff is that of the tanks,...

    The crux of the AP debuff is that of the tanks, two of four tanks have a baseline version (warriors/druids). Paladins can relatively easily get it, and in my view should have it given you're already...
  24. Replies
    41
    Views
    5,133

    Unholy is a specialized tank spec, and one I...

    Unholy is a specialized tank spec, and one I would actually favor for Festergut/Rotface's mechanics. Frost/Blood are easier to understand and employ, especially with Frost have a notable number of...
  25. Replies
    57
    Views
    4,801

    DK Tanks have IBF has a general cooldown, backed...

    DK Tanks have IBF has a general cooldown, backed up with a 1 min CD depending on spec. Also, DKs have AMS, which is surprisingly useful with a 45 second Cooldown. Generally, while IBF is good, it's...
Results 1 to 25 of 25