Prot Warrior Weapon Enchant
Ok, so the purpose of this thread is too look at the value of the various weapon enchants available right now and figure out which will actually hold more benefit. Namely:
Dancing Steel: Increases Strength or Agility by 1650 when dealing damage. Highest of the two stats is always chosen.
It has a proc-rate of 1 PPM and a *duration of 12 seconds, no ICD and will refresh itself should if it proc back to back. ONLY procs off an attack that lands*
*(UNCONFIRMED, read it in comments on wow-head.)
River's Song: Increases Dodge by 1650 when dealing damage for 7 seconds.
It has a proc rate of 2 PPM and *can proc off of attacks that are dodged/parried or miss. It can also stack with itself*
*(Once again, unconfirmed, read those parts in comments.)
I'm not including Windsong or Colossus in this comparison, you are free to do so if you wish in the comments should one of them just happen to be ridiculously better, contrary to my all to often in-accurate opinion.
Anyway, so basically the main reason for my hesitance to go with one or the other is the higher DR on Dodge VS the slightly decreased conversion rate of Strength to Parry. And then there are also the proc-rates which if you're fully hit/expertise capped would make them almost equal.
And last (and actually maybe least) strenght = AP which = a slightly heftier Sbar and a very minor dps boost. Though i don't think it will be that hefty of a difference to have it bare much weight.
Please leave all discussion about the costs out, for the sake of the discussion resources are not an issue under any circumstance.