Our Warrior Tank. . . . ?!
I'm hoping someone valiantly steps up and helps me out here. We have a warrior tank in our fairly accomplished 10 man guild that I am at odds with. . . . I play a feral tank, so I know plenty about tanking. . . enough to know that he is doing things wrong. I just don't know enough about Warrior to really help him.
Here is a link to his armory: The World of Warcraft Armory
The gear is the gear. He has only been back playing for about a month, and is working on getting it up where it should be. The real problem for me is his gem choices and his enchants. Raid buffed he is only at 39k. . . in caster form (Feral druid) I have that much. . . So I know something is wrong there. He is also absolutely sure (heh) that he needs to be at the hit cap, otherwise his threat will suck.
Currently, his threat is awesome. He pulls down a pretty steady 7500 tps, which is great. But I hold steady that a dead tank does 0 tps. I cant imagine dropping a bunch of +hit for +stam would have that big of an effect on his performance.
Can someone just verify for me that after the non-crit cap (its like 580 def, right?) that he needs to stack Stam for heroics/hardmodes/progression? And maybe give me an idea of what enchants he should be replacing.
Thanks so much for your time!