Im replacing my old trinket since its worthless now
Offering of Sacrifice
should i go with
Essence of the Gossamer
Darkmoon Card: Greatness
I already have 40% dodge but only 32k unbuffed HP
I use all three of the trinkets you mention, and I'll swap them in and out depending on the fight. Also going to get defenders code. Dont throw away trinkets with armor on them - they're still great for certain fights - you just dont get half a shield's worth of armor with them any more!
For the health proc really. But yes, the content is introductory, so advanced theorycrafting is irrelevant. Use the mirror of truth and the sphere of the red dragon when tanking if you really want :)