[Manßearpig]

I will preface this by saying that these items are for tanking Naxx and after 3.1 may no longer be as good as they are right now.


(Best Items for Mitigation/Survival are placed at the top of the list)

CLOAK

Flowing Cloak of Command
The Culling of Stratholme

Cloak of Tormented Skies
Crafted

Durable Nerubhide Cape
Crafted

Cloak of the Gushing Wound
Heroic Violet Hold

Ice Striker's Cloak
Crafted

Shroud of Reverberation
Heroic Halls of Lightning

__________________________________________________
WAIST

Sharp-Barbed Leather Belt
Heroic Utgarde Keep

Jorach's Crocolisk Skin Belt
40 Emblem of Heroism

Trollwoven Girdle
Crafted

Polar Cord
Crafted
*Best Effective Health piece*

__________________________________________________
SHOULDER

Trollwoven Spaulders
Crafted

Sprinting Shoulderpads
Heroic Ahn'kahet

Spaulders of the Careless Thief
Heroic The Nexus

__________________________________________________
BOOTS

Slag Footguards
Heroic Halls of Lightning

Gorloc Muddy Footwraps
Heroic Gundrak

Boots of the Neverending Path
Argent Crusade - Exalted

Boots of the Whirling Mist
Heroic Halls of Stone

Polar Boots
Crafted
*Best Effective Health Piece*

________________________________________
LEGS

Legguards of Swarming Attacks
Heroic Ahn'kahet

Gored Hide Legguards
Heroic Gundrak

Chain Gang Legguards
BoE (Rusted Footlocker in Dalaran)

Mind-Expanding Leggings
Kirin Tor - Revered

__________________________________________________
CHEST

Heroes' Dreamwalker Raiments
80 Emblem of Heroism

Crystal Infused Tunic
Heroic The Nexus

Exotic Leather Tunic
(Q) Junk in My Trunk / Utgarde Pinnacle

Polar Vest
Crafted
*Best Effective Health Piece*

__________________________________________________
HELM

Mask of the Watcher
Heroic Oculus

Shroud of Darkness
Heroic Violet Hold

Headguard of Retaliation
(Q) Vengeance will be Mine / Utgarde Pinnacle

__________________________________________________
NECK
(Until Armor Change)

Titanium Earthguard Chain
Crafted

Amulet of Wills
Halls of Stone

Chained Military Gorget
25 Emblem of Heroism
(After Armor change this becomes better)

Shadowseeker's Pendant
Heroic Ahn'kahet

__________________________________________________
BRACER

Bindings of the Tunneler
Heroic Utgarde Keep

Dragonfriend Bracers
Wyrmrest Accord - Exalted

Advanced Tooled-Leather Bands
Heroic Halls of Lightning

Drake-Champion's Bracers
Heroic The Oculus

__________________________________________________
GLOVES

Handwraps of Preserved History
(Q) A Royal Escort / The Culling of Stratholme

Heroes' Dreamwalker Handgrips
60 Emblem of Heroism

Charged-Bolt Grips
Heroic Halls of Lightning

__________________________________________________
RINGS
(Until Armor Change)

Keystone Great-Ring
Heroic Drak'Tharon Keep

Nerubian Shield Ring
Heroic Ahn'kahet

Band of Torture
Heroic The Oculus

Iceforged Battle Ring
(Q) The Brothers Bronzebeard / Stormpeaks

__________________________________________________
TRINKETS
(Until Armor Change)

Offering of Sacrifice
Heroic Gundrak

Essence of Gossamer
Heroic Azjol-Nerub

Valor Medal of the First War
40 Emblems of Heroism

Darkmoon Card: Greatness

__________________________________________________
WEAPON

Enraged Feral Staff
Heroic Utgarde Keep

Stave of Shrouded Mysteries
Kirin Tor Revered

__________________________________________________
*Edit*
Most of these gear choices are based on Rawr calculations. ( I am not sure where your pieces fall but from what i can tell a lot of them wont be preferable until the armor change at which time this list will have to be reworked. @Darksend)

I purposely left out profession specific items for JC or Engy.

The Epic leather pvp gear is best in slot for Mitigation/Survival should you wish to go that route:

Hateful Gladiator's Boots of Triumph
Hateful Gladiator's Armwraps of Triumph
Hateful Gladiator's Belt of Triumph

[Ciderhelm]

Aren't you... hey wait aren't you in class?

[Manßearpig]

yeah, im in Management Information Systems not doing anything.

[Halandir]

cool, nice work--I'm going to post a link to this in my guild forums

[Kazeyonoma]

lol some Vent speak is spilling over into the forums I c.

[Darksend]

working on the 10/25 man gear list is should be up by the end of week, removing all my clutter because manbears list agrees with most of my conclusions

and as he said almost non of my items work till after the armor change

[Manßearpig]

I would prefer if they were not combined. Most of these items are best in slot pre naxx.

[Darksend]

based on what math because i already see a few that are not.

[Manßearpig]

Well give me a non cloak example. Many lvl 70 cloaks are "better" because of armor than the ones at 80.
I'm not including pvp gear either. It is generally better.

[Darksend]

i am really just curious what method you use because i have no math to support anything and so much of it is sliding scale if i have 50 hit rating and you have 300 then obviously ur BIS and mine are way different for example the argent crusade exalted epic boots are my best in slot because of the 66 hit rating i can afford to take the stam hit because i have 2x stam trinkets


just as an edit

i am currently gearing for the patch and totally not even trying to get the 550 armor trinket, if it drops ill use it but i am not actively pursuing it

that may be another reason we differ so much

[Manßearpig]

I use rawr for much of my calculations. Because of this, my BIS items are focused almost exclusively on Mitigation/Survival. Threat is a small factor in the calculations but like any gear list, you have to set your own opportunity costs for the fight.

If your EH is fine and you aren't in danger of getting 3 shot, then it might be ok to drop 40 stam from your boots for 56 hit and 9 agi.
But maybe not.

Slag Footguards with 15 stam/10 hit
Boots of the Neverending Path - Item - World of Warcraft

*edit*
In this gearset i have 113 hit and 202 expertise

You can always get some Hit food if you are hurting.

[Manßearpig]

Aye, this is specifically gearing up for Naxx prepatch.

I don't expect 3.1 to come out before i am through clearing naxx though.

[Stearns]

Thanks for a great set of item lists guys!

[Genova]

Holy Wall of Items Batman, thanks Gives me something to do today.

[Banx]

Great job Manbearpig and Darksend. Always great to see some drood love, especially with these latest changes in gear. Please keep us posted as to how we're shaping up against our counterparts.

With what I've read, it's looking like Blizz is looking to try to make all of the tanking classes comparable, but in doing so are hurting the fuzzy tanks.

Looks like I'm going back to rolling against rogues again

Again, thanks and keep up the good work mate.

[Tavia]

Cheers for the list, Manbearpig - I agree with your choises (And I am so fortunate, that I actually have gotten my hands (paws) on a few of them myself).
Also to you, Darksend, for providing your list

One slot is missing, tho - Idols.

As far as I know, there are only two options for a feral tank in WotLK so far:

Idol of Perspicacious Attacks - 30 venture Coins - only lvl 74.

Savage Gladiator's Idol of Resolve - Honor points - lvl. 80

Neither are fantastic IMO (I might be wrong off course).

Just looking at it (And I have not done the math, to back up my statement), isn't Idol of Terror (20 badges of Justice - lvl. 70) one of the best options avaliable.

Any feedback would be appreciated.

Best regards

/Tavia @ Dragonmaw

[Manßearpig]

Aye, you are correct Tavia. Unfortunately there are no Tanking idols in WotLK right now.

I use Idol of Perspicacious Attacks because i like to see bit Maul crits but for what its worth, Idol of Terror is still better for Mitigation if only slightly

I would like something useful. Maybe a defensive bonus like:

Idol of Tanking
"While Lacerate is applied to target you gain X% dodge to attacks from that target".

[dynamitedean]

What weapon enchant do you recommend...i heard that stuff like mongoose procs for druids now but I've always just stuck with +35agi

[Manßearpig]

35 AGI is unfortunately still the best Tanking enchant. Static dodge is better than the random proc of mongoose while tanking and now AP scales far better than AGI for dps as well.

Massacre (110 AP) is what i will be using until something better comes along.

Lifeward might be something to look into but not till i can get some solid parses on the proc rates.

[Darksend]

ive been EXTREMLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY busy but i should have my 10/25 man guide out sometime in the next 2 weeks

i have it all in word but for some reason every time i copy and paste from word all the links break and the formating goes all screwy so im having to redo the whole thing (its also from beta and is missing some stuff so i have to double recheck everything)