[Korlong]

Gloves of Calculated Risk - Item - World of Warcraft should probably be on the list there somewhere.

[DeviousOne]

Hmmm. I'll keep that in mind. I'm hitting 4k AP, 38% crit rate, and I have 313 hit rating. I feel my hit is a little low, would like it to be around 350 hit.

[Graul]

Source: Corbusier You don't have any actual math to back up your assumptions either, and you're stating your opinions as if they were facts. I have neither trinket, but from eyeballing the two trinkets, Grim Toll is better. .

Hmm...

[Aganon]

Source: Graul Hmm...

Then the new registrant finished reading the post and was astonished at seeing a complete thought.

[Korlong]

If that's GRAUL Graul, he at least has some credibility, if something of an ego on him.

[Graul]

Quite a few "known" Warriors have egos, but that's beside the point. I'm just giving Corb a hard time because he's criticizing someone for doing something specific and in the same post does the same thing he's criticizing him for. He's a big boy though and probably figured it out on his own.

[Corbusier]

I never stated my opinion as fact, and I clearly stated what assumptions I was working under.

Not like it matters anyway, both trinkets kinda blow.

[Gaug]

Please add:

Ranged: Nerubian Conqueror, 10 man Nax, Nerubian Conquerer - Item - World of Warcraft

Neck: Fool's Trial, 25 man Nax, Fool's Trial - Item - World of Warcraft

[greasy]

Could you please add:

Trinket: Fezzik's Pocketwatch - Quest Reward - Fezzik's Pocketwatch - Item - World of Warcraft

[Alkthree]

Noob question here, What does SEP stand for?

[thrannix]

Corb,

Could you please add:

Belt: Stalk-Skin Belt, 25 man Naxx, Stalk-Skin Belt - Item - World of Warcraft

Thanks.

[Eeeeeeeeeekz]

is there a way to organize these by plate /mail type order?

[Snooze]

Hi there! I noticed Valorous Dreadnaught Gauntlets - Item - World of Warcraft were not on your list (Unless I'm blind)

Also, using your SEP values, Nesingwary 4000 has a SEP value of 54 if you don't include the gem slot, but if you include the gem slot and use an Inscribed monarch topaz then the SEP value is 72.8

Alkthree, SEP stands for Strength Equivalence Points if I'm not mistaken

And thanks for putting this guide up, Corb

[Evilbrut]

I would add Jewelcrafters BOE epic ring and neck

[Jardon]

Not sure if anyone caught it yet, but Melancholy Sabatons are from Eye of Eternity 25, not Naxx 25.

[Nuberino]

To save your sanity, I would think it would be easier to just use WoWHeads sort and filtering system... while not perfect at least you wouldn't have to keep updating a list and calculating SEP. I thought this already posted but I didn't see it in a quick scan of the thread.

For instance, gloves (plate, mail, leather) sorted by weights given by Corb at the initial post:

Armor - Items - World of Warcraft

[Alkthree]

Titanium impact band is missing from rings

[Alkthree]

And thanks Snooze

[Tidas]

I noticed the Fool's Trial neckpiece isnt on there. Think you could evaluate it and toss it in there?

[Rufa]

I used Corbusier's SEP scheme in Wowhead and the results don't quite match.

Source: Corbusier 1 STR = 1 SEP 1 AP = .45 SEP 1 Crit Rating = .9 SEP 1 AGI = .75 SEP 1 Haste Rating = .55 SEP 1 ArP Rating = .5 SEP 1 Hit Rating = .3 SEP 1 Expertise Rating = 1.1 SEP 1 Armor = .0075 SEP

Here's the Wowhead link I used: Armor - Items - World of Warcraft

Is this because Wowhead calculates the weighting differently?