Prot Warrior trinket question

[Khazzeron]

So I was using http://www.wowhead.com/item=56347 and http://www.wowhead.com/item=56449

Now I aquired http://www.wowhead.com/item=62471 and I'm trying to figure out which to replace. I"m a mastery stacked tank.

Without the Mirror I'm 152k hp unbuffed, and 77.89% avoidance. (77.4 needed for "unhittable")

When I replace my stam trinket, with mirror, i'm 144k unbuffed and 80.58% avoidance. (29% crit block)

With replacing the Throngus, i got 152k hp, 79.28% avoidance. But lose parry/dodge, guess it's not a big overall diff but still...atm I was replacing the stam atm but not sure what to do o.o

[theodisius]

It's a trade off between melee damage reduction and effective health. I'd be inclined to keep both and swap depending on the fight. For magic heavy fights, keep the stamina; for 5-man trash, go MDR. At the moment, I'm inclined to use a stamina trinket for raiding although as we gear up, that may be dispensible.

Over time, I would look to replace the finger with a second mastery trinket, as that would be more consistent with your gearing strategy. The other TB trinket (with agility on use = 4% dodge) would be good.