When is it too much defense?

[markv]

I know, right, how is this even possible you ask? I'm at the point where I think I'm just at too much, and wondering what would offer a better return on two spots.

Enchant Chest: Currently 22d, would it better to be swapping to 10 all stats or 275 health?

Enchant Shield: Currently 20d, would it be better to be swapping to 18sta or Titanium plating.

Prot Warrior is what I play.

Your guys thoughts on it?

The World of Warcraft Armory (http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Ysera&n=Kguku)

[Gorbachop]

Armory Link?

[markv]

I added it in to my original post. I think I'm going to go swapping to health route.

I noticed you are doing 18sta on gloves, you prefer that over armsman even tho the parry return on points invested was improved?

[Gorbachop]

I'm a stam whore for sure and according to TankPoints in game, 10 parry rating is only .13% avoidance. The 2% threat is a non-issue.

Even with your defense enchants you have less defense than I do. Unless you are stacking defense gems/enchants I don't see there ever being too much of it from gear.

Personally, I would switch the chest and shield enchants, but that's me.

[Strit]

yeah. 549 isn't over the top really. i think it suits you just fine. :)

[markv]

Yeah I was at 561 before I did the swapping to the health enchants.

[Mert]

Sounds like you've already taken it, but Super Health is better than +10 Stats, definitely, especially for a Warrior (though I still see too many Paladins with it too, in my opinion).